Knife 101, Part Deux
I was watching an older episode of Good Eats, “American Slicer,” and was inspired to write about my personal views on the knife.
We had already posted something on the subject awhile aback; I highly suggest you read it if you want to increase your slicer knowledge. One of the best tips is that you only need 3-4 knives and not a dozen or so. However, personally, I’m a minimalist and think that you only really need two: a medium-sized chef’s knife and a serrated blade. A medium-sized chef’s knife will take care of virtually all your knife needs even paring. Unfortunately, there is one task that even a good chef’s knife can’t handle. To put it brusquely, a chef’s knife can’t saw food. Certain things such as bread and tomatoes need more of a sawing action to get the job done.
Today, I wanted to focus on choosing a good chef’s knife. Since it’s the tool that will take care of much of your slicing, dicing, chopping needs, it’s important to choose the right knife for you.
I had a friend ask me why on earth should she purchase an expensive knife when she could purchase an entire knife set at WalMart for $20. Sadly, back then, I couldn’t quite articulate my arguments well enough to stop her from purchasing the cheap knife set. I rolled my eyes at the misguided choice.
However, now, I can explain why you should pay three times as much for one good knife as opposed to an entire set of cheap knives.
Let’s start with stamped vs. forged knives. Stamped knives are cut from rolled steal into templates and then sharpened. The steel itself is light, and the knife itself will lack density and weight. The process isn’t as labor intensive as forging blades and the material generally cheaper. Although you can find pricier stamped blades, generally speaking, they are cheap $20 set variety you can find at your local big box store.
You can find an expensive set of stamped knives like shown on the left. Wusthof makes a very decent knife; that I am not contesting. The problem is that it doesn’t change the fact that it is stamped.
Stamped knives, due to their low density and overall softness, do not hold their edges for too long. You will need to sharpen them more frequently than forged ones.
The biggest problem I have with stamped knives is really the fact that they are light. I like my blade to have some weight on it. A knife with heft and a reliable edge will always do you right. Because the blade is so light on a stamped knife, you will need more force and tighter grip which can all result in an injury. Poor fingers….ouch.
Forged knives make me smile. These knives are worked over in an intricate process of heating and molding and then expertly polished and sharpened. Think of the old samurai movies where the sword smith tires over extreme heat with a hammer and you have a good idea what I’m talking about. Well almost.
Forged knives have good weight and will give you the precision you need for expert slicing, dicing, and chopping. Furthermore, they are more economical since you only really need one good knife, and you won’t have to sharpen as much.
So what do I recommend?
I have a thing for J.A. Henckels, an old and respected German brand of knives and cutlery. They make seriously good knives. They can be pricey, but it is so worth the investment. I suggest getting a santoku knife from Henckels.
This particular model is 7 inches, the perfect size for a multitasking knife. Notice the shape of the blade. It’s formed for ease of use on the the wrist. Furthermore, the recessed edge make it easier to ply food off the blade. No more pesky veggies to scrape off your blade.
This beautifully blade can be yours for the low, low price of around $40-50. Believe, you’ll be glad you made the investment.
I’ve been using a Henckel’s for about 7 years now and won’t ever use another knife. It’s been a pleasure to use. No, Henckel’s isn’t paying me to say this
Either way, buy a good, forged knife. Your cooking will improve and your uninjured fingers will thank you.










